The Question Behind the Question

Is Archer Aviation a good stock to buy? The honest answer is that it is a serious company in a serious sector, and it is also a pre-revenue startup whose aircraft has not reached commercial production yet. Those two facts have to be held together, and the Uber Air pitch from The Crow’s Nest is part of the reason the question comes up so often, because it frames the whole eVTOL category as a single big win and points at Joby Aviation (JOBY) as the inevitable winner.

Archer Aviation (ACHR) is the other side of that story. It builds an electric vertical takeoff and landing aircraft called Midnight, and it has two heavyweights behind it. Stellantis is its manufacturing partner with roughly a 10.4 percent stake. United Airlines, through United Airlines Ventures, has ordered the aircraft. In total Archer has raised more than $1.1 billion, and its FAA certification is in progress. That is a real foundation, and it is why Archer is the credible challenger rather than a footnote.

What Would Have to Go Right

For Archer to be a good stock to buy, several things have to happen in sequence. It has to finish FAA Type Certification, which converts a test program into a product it can sell. It has to move Midnight into volume production, which is where the Stellantis relationship matters most. Then it has to fill real routes with paying passengers, which is where United’s network matters. Each step is slow, capital-hungry, and not guaranteed.

That is the same gauntlet Joby is running, and Joby is further along on most of it. Joby holds the earliest revenue in the sector, a balance sheet with roughly $2.3 billion in cash, and the furthest certification progress among Western eVTOL names. That gap is the central tension in any Archer decision: the challenger is credible, but the leader has a head start.

How the Comparison Breaks Down

On cash, Joby is ahead, with a much larger cushion than Archer’s roughly $1.1 billion in total funding. On certification, both are in process, with Joby regarded as furthest along. On manufacturing, both have real partners, Stellantis for Archer and Toyota, which has invested roughly $894 million in Joby, for the leader. On demand, United backs Archer while Delta backs Joby. The two have built near-mirror-image coalitions, which is why our Joby vs Archer breakdown treats this as a genuine rivalry rather than a foregone conclusion.

The price story is where the caution lives. The promo’s “$10 to over $200” target rests on fleet math, roughly 14,000 aircraft earning meaningful profit by 2035, that no company in the sector is close to supporting. Joby flies about five aircraft with twelve in production. Archer is still moving toward production. A sector this early does not have a “$200 stock” hiding in it, regardless of which name the pitch prefers.

The Commercial Reality

The first commercial service in this category will be a premium shuttle, not a mass-market taxi. It will run airport routes like Manhattan to JFK and Downtown Dallas at roughly $150 to $300 a seat, the “Uber Black Air” model. That is a real niche, but it is a niche, and it is where both Archer and Joby will earn their first real revenue. The size of that first market is a lot smaller than the flying-car fantasy the headlines trade on.

For the leader’s side of the comparison, our Joby Aviation stock analysis walks through the tease price, the fleet math, and the revenue mix in full.

The Honest Read

Archer Aviation is a legitimate company with legitimate partners and a real shot at the number-two slot in Western eVTOL. But “good stock to buy” is a claim about valuation and timing, and a pre-revenue aircraft startup before certification is a watch-list name, not a conviction buy. Watch for certification, first production, and first revenue. Those are the signals that will answer the question better than any headline.

A Checklist Before Buying

If the question is whether Archer Aviation (ACHR) is a buy, the cleanest answer is a short checklist. Has the company finished FAA Type Certification? Has the Midnight aircraft moved from prototypes to volume production on the Stellantis line? Has the company reported its first meaningful commercial revenue, and on which routes? And how does its cash position look relative to the years of funding still ahead?

Right now the honest answers are “not yet” on the first three, and “enough to keep going, but thinner than the leader” on the fourth. That is not a condemnation; it is the normal profile of an early-stage challenger. The checklist is useful precisely because it converts a vague question into dated milestones. When those milestones start landing, the buy case will make itself. Until they do, Archer is best held as a watch-list name, with Joby Aviation (JOBY) as the sector’s steadier anchor.

NewsletterVetter is an independent publication. We receive compensation from some of the services we review through affiliate links. Nothing on this site is investment advice. Always do your own research.