Eagle Financial’s “10.3% War Bond” pitch includes a line designed to appeal to anyone tired of Wall Street: “No bankers, no brokers, no Wall Street middlemen.” It is a powerful framing, and it is misleading. Annuities are sold on commission. Someone is getting paid to sell you this contract, and the cost is built into the payout you receive. The question is not whether there is a middleman. The question is how much of your money never reaches your pocket.
The Commission Structure
Annuity commissions vary widely by product type. A plain income annuity, the kind behind the “10.3% War Bond” pitch, typically pays the selling agent 1% to 4% of the premium. On a $200,000 contract, that is $2,000 to $8,000. The commission is not disclosed as a line item on your statement. It is paid by the insurance company out of its profit margin and effectively reduces the payout you receive.
More complex annuities pay substantially higher commissions. Fixed index annuities and variable annuities commonly pay 4% to 7% of the premium. On that same $200,000, the commission could reach $14,000. These products also carry ongoing fees: mortality and expense charges, administrative fees, rider charges for income guarantees or death benefits, and surrender charges that penalize early withdrawals, sometimes for seven to ten years.
The commission structure creates an incentive problem. The products that pay the highest commissions to agents tend to be the most complex, the least transparent, and the least favorable to the buyer. A plain income annuity like the one Eagle Financial is promoting through Todd Phillips of Phillips Financial Services (founded by his father Dave Phillips, with an Estate Planning Specialists subsidiary) sits at the simpler, lower-commission end of the spectrum. But it is still a commissioned product, and the cost is still built into the payout rate you see.
Where the Money Goes
To understand the true cost of an income annuity, you have to trace the entire chain. You pay the insurer $200,000. The insurer pays a commission to the agent. The insurer invests the remaining funds in bonds and sets aside reserves. The insurer calculates a payout rate that covers its costs, produces a profit, and gives you a competitive monthly check.
The payout rate you see, roughly 7.5% for immediate income or 10.3% with a roughly five-year deferral for a couple both age 69, is the result after all of these costs have been subtracted. You never see a line item for the commission. You never see the insurer’s profit margin. The costs are invisible, baked into the spread between what the insurer earns on its bond portfolio and what it pays you.
The “No Middlemen” Claim
Eagle Financial’s copywriter, Roger Michalski, crafts the pitch around a populist theme: bypass Wall Street, avoid the brokers, keep more of your money. But the product is sold through insurance agents who earn a commission. Todd Phillips, the presenter, runs a financial planning practice with an Estate Planning Specialists subsidiary. He is the middleman, or at least the face of a distribution network that includes middlemen.
This is not to say Phillips is doing anything dishonest. He is selling a regulated insurance product through a legal, established distribution channel. The problem is the pitch. When the ad says “no brokers, no middlemen,” it creates the impression that you are getting direct access to something Wall Street insiders do not want you to know about. In reality, you are buying an annuity through an insurance agent, the same as you would through any other channel.
For more on how this compares to other income products being marketed to retirees, see our analysis of the Oxford Income Letter’s 29 Account.
Hidden Costs Beyond the Commission
Income annuities also carry an illiquidity cost. Once you pay your premium, the money is gone. If you need $50,000 for an emergency, you cannot sell a slice of your annuity the way you could sell a bond.
Plain income annuities avoid most of these explicit fees. There are no surrender charges, no mortality and expense ratios, and no ongoing management fees because there is nothing to manage. The cost is the spread between the bond yield the insurer earns and the payout rate you receive. For more on what the contract actually guarantees, see our piece on what is a guaranteed annuity.
How to Evaluate the Cost
The simplest way to evaluate an income annuity is to compare its payout rate to the bond yield you could earn on your own. If the 30-year Treasury yields 5.2% and the immediate annuity pays roughly 7.5% for a 69-year-old couple, the extra 2.3 points represent mortality credits plus the return of your own principal. You cannot replicate the mortality credit yourself.
For a fuller picture of how the product works, see our explainer on the annuity product behind the pitch.
The Bottom Line on Costs
There is no free lunch in annuities. The “no middlemen” line is marketing, not reality: the product is sold on commission, the costs are buried in the payout rate, and the illiquidity is real. The income annuity here is among the more transparent products, but transparency is relative. You cannot see the commission, you cannot see the insurer’s profit margin, and you cannot get your money back once it is paid.
Todd Phillips runs a legitimate practice and the annuity is real, with rates elevated for genuine macro reasons: 5.2% 30-year Treasuries and competition from Apollo and Brookfield’s annuity platforms. But the framing of a secret, middleman-free bond is wrong. There is a cost, it is built into the math, and the 10.3% number only makes sense once you see what is subtracted before the check arrives.
Ready to see the research? Click here to access Todd Phillips’s report.
NewsletterVetter is an independent publication. We receive compensation from some of the services we review through affiliate links. Nothing on this site is investment advice. Always do your own research.