The Best of Both Worlds
Gold dividend stocks are the sector’s attempt to solve a problem that has always dogged gold investors: the metal pays you nothing, so owning it is a pure bet on price appreciation. A gold miner that pays a dividend changes that, handing you an income stream while you wait for the metal to rise. Garrett Goggin’s “Debt Free Gold ‘Annuity’” pitch is the purest expression of that idea, because its pick, Lundin Gold, is designed to pay income now and track gold’s upside later.
The mechanism that makes this work is a dividend split into two parts. There is a fixed component, a stable quarterly payment funded by a minimum three-hundred-million-dollar annual allocation, and a variable component of at least fifty percent of normalized free cash flow, which rises and falls with the gold price. The fixed part gives you the income, and the variable part gives you the gold exposure. It is the closest thing the sector has to a payout that offers both.
How the Fixed-Plus-Variable Payout Works
The most recent quarter illustrates the design. The company paid a dollar fourteen cents a share in total, made up of a thirty-cent fixed component and an eighty-four-cent variable piece. Earlier in the year, when gold prices were higher, the total reached a dollar twenty-one cents. That variation is the whole point: the dividend is not static, it breathes with the metal, which means the yield you actually receive depends on where gold trades.
That is also where the “annuity” label runs into reality. An annuity is a fixed, contractual stream of payments. This dividend’s variable component is discretionary and moves with cash flow, so it is more like an income stream that tracks the gold price than an insurance product. Our teardown puts the honest yield at roughly six and a half percent rather than the “up to 10%” headline, and notes that the twelve percent figure floating around is a double-count of the two components.
The Gold Upside Case
The upside case is what separates this from a bond. If gold rises, the variable component rises with it, because free cash flow expands faster than costs when the metal price climbs. Goggin’s own copy makes the point bluntly: “if gold goes up to $5,500, that profit soars to 100% or more.” The historical anchors he cites, Homestake reaching a seventy percent yield-on-cost by 1936 and Wiluna Gold at twenty-two and a half percent in 1934, are meant to show what a low-cost miner’s payout can do in a gold bull.
Those examples are real but come with the standard caveat. They measure yield on an original cost basis for long-held positions, not the yield a new buyer receives today. A new investor steps into the current mid-single-digit yield and hopes the dividend grows from here. The upside is genuine; it just is not a guarantee.
The Risk You Are Paid For
The income does not come free. The yield is compensation for concentration risk, because everything the company owns is one mine in Ecuador, a country the Fraser Institute ranks in its bottom ten jurisdictions and where an active tax-and-royalty audit is underway. A diversified gold producer pays less but carries less single-asset risk; this name pays more precisely because it carries more.
For the yield-and-safety tradeoff, see our best gold dividend stocks list and our gold stocks that pay dividends list. For the company behind the pitch, read our Lundin Gold profile.
Reading the Yield Honestly
A yield figure is only as good as the assumptions behind it, and gold dividend stocks are a common place for those assumptions to break down. The first thing to check is whether the number is trailing or forward, because a trailing yield reflects dividends already paid, while a forward yield guesses at future payments that depend on the gold price. The second is whether the number double-counts a multi-part dividend, which is exactly what happens with the twelve percent figure that circulates for Lundin Gold: it adds the fixed and variable components as if they were two separate yields stacked on top of each other, when they are really two parts of one payout.
The honest way to read the yield is to annualize the most recent quarter and divide by the current share price. For Lundin Gold, a dollar-fourteen-cent quarterly dividend near a seventy-dollar share price works out to roughly six and a half percent, which is strong for a gold miner but a long way from the “up to 10%” headline. The gap between the headline and the honest number is not dishonesty on the company’s part; it is the difference between a marketing ceiling and a current reality. The yield can rise toward double digits, but only if gold cooperates and the variable component climbs with it.
None of this means the yield is bad. A mid-single-digit yield on a zero-debt, low-cost miner is genuinely attractive, and it compares well against the diversified majors that pay far less. The point is only to read the number for what it is, a current income stream with upside tied to the metal, rather than a guaranteed double-digit coupon. An investor who buys the honest six and a half percent and is pleasantly surprised by more is in a much better position than one who buys expecting ten and is disappointed.
Ready to see the research? Click here to access Garrett Goggin’s report.
NewsletterVetter is an independent publication. We receive compensation from some of the services we review through affiliate links. Nothing on this site is investment advice. Always do your own research.