The Service
The Oxford Income Letter is The Oxford Club’s dividend-focused newsletter, run by Marc Lichtenfeld, and it normally does exactly what its name suggests: it hunts for reliable income. The current pitch, though, is dressed up in the most dramatic framing the publisher has used in a while, “the single biggest threat SpaceX has ever faced.” We decoded the stocks involved and checked whether an income letter should really be recommending them. Here is our honest review. We walk through the specifics in our Oxford Income Letter piece.
A Dividend Authority
Lichtenfeld is a genuine authority on income investing. He is the author of “Get Rich with Dividends,” a book that lays out a systematic, repeatable approach to dividend growth, and he has spent his career explaining compounding to retail investors. His framework, buy companies that raise their dividends every year, is the rare kind of advice that works in both up and down markets. That credibility is why the current pitch is worth scrutinizing carefully, because it departs from the playbook he is known for.
The Pitch, Decoded
The hook is a real event. In 2021, during the COVID waves, SpaceX leadership publicly warned that a liquid oxygen shortage could stall launches. The promo uses that scare to point at two names: Linde (LIN), the industrial gas giant that actually supplies the liquid oxygen, and Vale (VALE), the Brazilian mining giant. Our full teardown walks through both.
The problem is that the two names belong to two different stories. Linde’s is the liquid oxygen story, and we covered it separately in our look at Linde stock. Vale’s is a Tesla story, not a SpaceX story: long-range EVs use high-nickel batteries, and Elon Musk really did call nickel supply his biggest concern. The promo mashes both under one SpaceX headline, but a rocket burns liquid oxygen while a car battery runs on nickel, and the only thing uniting them is that the same person runs both companies.
The Vale Fine Print
Vale is one of the largest mining companies on earth, and its two big products are iron ore and nickel. The thing the promo hides is what actually drives Vale’s earnings: Chinese steel demand. Most of its iron ore is sold to China, which means Vale’s revenue engine is property and infrastructure spending in Beijing, not SpaceX, not Tesla, not even batteries. Nickel for EVs is a real, long-run growth theme, but it is the smaller, more volatile part of the story.
There is also the income question, which matters a lot for a dividend letter. Vale pays a dividend, and it can be a large one, but it is a variable payout tied to commodity prices, not the steady, growing stream an income investor is looking for. It has been cut in down cycles before. For readers focused on the mineral side of the energy transition, our piece on critical minerals stocks is a better map of the terrain.
What the Oxford Income Letter Does Well
The $99 price with a 365-day refund is genuinely consumer-friendly, and it is the rare newsletter that lets you look at the research for a full year and still walk away with your money back. The underlying picks, Linde and Vale, are real, world-class companies with real earnings, not promotional shells. And the nickel-for-batteries thesis is a legitimate multi-decade theme.
What to Consider
The packaging is the issue. A “secret supplier” framing for a $50 billion blue-chip miner is misleading, and the SpaceX scare headline points at a liquid oxygen supplier that is a different company from the one an income investor would actually be buying. The letter’s own identity, dependable income, collides with a commodity cyclical whose payout rises and falls with prices it cannot control.
For a cleaner read on the energy-income angle that fits the letter’s actual mission, our look at oil and gas royalties covers the kind of steady payout Lichtenfeld is normally known for.
The Verdict
The Oxford Income Letter is a legitimate dividend service with a credible analyst at the helm. Vale is a real company, and the nickel thesis has a long runway. But you should buy the miner on its own cyclical merits, not because of a SpaceX scare story that does not actually touch Vale’s business. If you want Lichtenfeld’s dividend framework, subscribe for that. If you want a nickel and iron ore position, that is a commodity call, and it deserves to be made with your eyes open.
NewsletterVetter is an independent publication. We receive compensation from some of the services we review through affiliate links. Nothing on this site is investment advice. Always do your own research.