Vale (VALE) is not a name most income investors connect to SpaceX, and that gap is exactly where Marc Lichtenfeld’s latest Oxford Income Letter pitch does its work. His promo, which he frames around the single biggest threat SpaceX has ever faced, quietly points at a Brazilian mining giant as a way to ride the Elon Musk story. The real company is more interesting than the tease, and it has a lot less to do with rockets than the headline suggests. Our Sherritt International: What You Need to Know explainer covers this in detail.
What Vale Actually Is
Vale is one of the largest mining companies on the planet, headquartered in Brazil and traded in the United States as an American depositary receipt. At the October 27 close of roughly $11.84, its market capitalization sat around $50.39 billion, which makes it a large, liquid, blue-chip mining name rather than the undiscovered chokepoint play the promo’s tone implies.
Its two flagship products are iron ore and nickel, with copper and a few other metals as smaller contributors. Iron ore is the main event. Vale ranks among the world’s biggest producers, and most of that ore is sold into China, where it feeds the steel industry that builds apartments, bridges, rail, and factories. Nickel is the secondary but faster-growing business, and it is the part that ties into the battery narrative.
The Musk Connection Runs Through Nickel
The SpaceX hook in the pitch is actually someone else’s story. The single biggest threat SpaceX has ever faced refers to a 2021 liquid oxygen shortage, and the company that supplied SpaceX’s liquid oxygen is Linde, an industrial gas giant we have covered elsewhere on this site. Vale does not sell liquid oxygen to SpaceX at all.
Its Musk connection runs through nickel and Tesla instead. Long-range Teslas use high-nickel battery chemistries, and Elon Musk really did call nickel supply his single biggest concern on an earnings call. So the thread from Vale to Musk is real, but it runs through electric-vehicle batteries, not rocket fuel. That is a meaningful distinction, because a rocket’s fuel supply chain and a car battery’s metal supply chain are two entirely different businesses.
The Income Wrinkle
The Oxford Income Letter branding matters here, because Vale’s dividend is not the steady, growing payout an income investor is usually hunting for. Vale pays a variable dividend tied to commodity prices and free cash flow. When iron ore is strong, the payout can look generous. When prices fall, the payout gets cut, and it has been cut before. That is the normal life of a cyclical miner, and it sits awkwardly inside a product called the Income Letter.
The tease-price math tells the same cyclical story. Vale closed around $11.84 against a tease price of $13.02, down roughly 9 percent. That is not a broken thesis; it is just what a commodity stock does between the day an ad is written and the day a reader sees it. The direction is being set by iron ore and nickel markets, not by anything happening at a launch pad.
The Real Driver Is China
If you want to know what moves Vale, ignore the rockets and watch Chinese property. Iron ore prices live and die with Chinese steel demand, which tracks construction and infrastructure spending. Nickel prices have been pulled around for years by a wave of Indonesian supply, even as electric-vehicle demand keeps growing. Those forces set Vale’s earnings, and they are the story the SpaceX packaging hides.
We unpack the major nickel producers in our nickel companies explainer, and the China-driven iron ore angle in our iron ore stocks piece. For the full breakdown of the promo, see our SpaceX biggest threat teardown.
The Offer and How to Think About It
The Oxford Income Letter sells for $99 a year with a 365-day refund, which is genuinely consumer-friendly by newsletter standards and gives a reader a low-risk way to inspect the research before committing. The pitch frames Vale as the answer to a SpaceX supply threat, but the honest way to evaluate Vale is on its own cyclical merits, not through a rocket launch headline.
That means asking two questions before buying. First, what is your view on Chinese steel demand, since iron ore is the engine behind Vale’s earnings. Second, what is your view on the nickel supply wave out of Indonesia, since that sets the ceiling on the battery-metal side of the business. If both look favorable, Vale is a reasonable, liquid way to own them. If you are buying only because of a SpaceX story, you are buying the wrong thesis.
Ready to see the research? Click here to access Marc Lichtenfeld’s report.
NewsletterVetter is an independent publication. We receive compensation from some of the services we review through affiliate links. Nothing on this site is investment advice. Always do your own research.