MP Materials (MP) is not the pick in Jim Rickards’ “Dow 100K” presentation. It is the template the pitch uses to sell the pick. The presentation tells the story of a rare-earth miner whose shares rose sharply after the United States government took an equity stake in it, and it uses that story to argue that a smaller, unnamed “next MP Materials” is about to repeat the trade. Understanding MP Materials is therefore the fastest way to understand what the pitch is actually asking you to believe.
The DoD Stake Story
The proof point is real. In 2025 the US government made an equity investment in MP Materials, the largest rare-earth producer in the United States, as part of a broader push to reduce dependence on Chinese processing of critical minerals. The presentation cites the resulting move in the stock, quoting gains as high as 228% in a little over three months and, in later passages, 348% in four months. That is a dramatic move, and it is the kind of number that makes a marketing pitch land.
MP Materials operates the Mountain Pass mine in California, the only scaled rare-earth mine and processing operation in the country, and it has been building out domestic separation and magnet production to close the loop that currently runs through China. The DoD stake was a genuine policy event, and the administration has publicly discussed equity investments in critical-minerals companies more broadly, which gives the pitch’s framing a foundation in fact rather than invention.
The Template, Not the Pick
The important distinction is that MP Materials is the “before” picture. The presentation’s actual recommendation is a different, smaller company it calls “the next MP Materials,” and that name is never printed in the free material. Our read of the clues points toward a rare-earth name in the metallurgical-coal-to-rare-earth space, a company with Ramaco fingerprints, but that is a fingerprint match, not a confirmation. The pitch does not name it.
That matters because the entire upside argument depends on the smaller company receiving the same kind of government attention MP Materials already received. The pitch even frames it that way, suggesting a direct government investment in the company “could happen at any moment.” Talks are not commitments, and a fingerprint match is not a ticker.
The Rare-Earth Thesis Itself
The underlying case for rare earths is stronger than the specific pick. These metals, neodymium, praseodymium, dysprosium, and the rest, go into the permanent magnets that power electric motors, wind turbines, and defense systems, and the presentation argues demand could rise dramatically over the next two decades. China controls the overwhelming majority of the world’s processing, which is the strategic vulnerability the US policy push is trying to close.
That is a real, structural story. The question is not whether rare earths matter. It is whether a specific small miner will be the beneficiary of a specific government action on a specific timeline. The pitch collapses that uncertainty into certainty, and the MP Materials history is doing the persuasive work.
The Valuation Question
For MP Materials itself, the numbers are worth a close look because the company is the reality check on the whole category. It is a real producer with real revenue, and its stock is priced for a policy tailwind that is partly realized and partly aspirational. The 228% and 348% moves the pitch quotes were event-driven spikes, and investors should treat them as what they were: a re-rating on a single government decision, not a steady-state growth rate.
That is the honest read. MP Materials is a legitimate, strategically important company, and the DoD stake was a real milestone. But it is the template, not the pick, and the pitch’s “next MP Materials” is unconfirmed. For the actual free ticker in the presentation, see our Range Resources piece. For the macro frame the whole thing sits inside, read the Dow Jones stocks explainer. And for Rickards’ earlier rare-earth campaign, see our Birthright rare-earth coverage.
The Competitive Picture
The strategic case is easiest to see when you map where the metal actually moves. China controls the vast majority of rare-earth mining and nearly all of the downstream processing, which means a single policy decision in Beijing can reprice the entire magnet supply chain. MP Materials is the main American attempt to break that dependence, and its Mountain Pass operation plus its domestic magnet plant in Texas are the only integrated US answer at scale. The other notable non-Chinese producer is Lynas, an Australian company that processes ore in Malaysia and is now building a US facility in Texas.
That concentration cuts both ways. It is the reason the US government is willing to write equity checks, and it is also the reason rare-earth prices swing hard. When China tightens export controls or when defense spending ramps, names in the space re-rate quickly, exactly the kind of move the MP Materials story captured. When the cycle eases, they give it back just as fast. Investors sizing up the category should read the DoD stake as a real catalyst and the volatility as a permanent feature, not a one-time event.
Ready to see the research? Click here to access Jim Rickards’s report.
NewsletterVetter is an independent publication. We receive compensation from some of the services we review through affiliate links. Nothing on this site is investment advice. Always do your own research.