Why Gold and Silver Stocks Are Moving
Gold has been in a strong uptrend, and every gold-stock promo now launches from that tailwind. Central banks have been buying bullion at the heaviest clip in decades, and the price of gold has climbed to levels that would have sounded extreme a few years ago. Silver tends to follow gold, usually with more volatility in both directions. That is the backdrop for Jim Rickards’s current presentation, “Trump’s Secret $2 Gold Mine,” which rides the metal’s momentum to sell a specific mining story.
The promotional logic is simple: if gold keeps rising, the companies that own gold in the ground should rise even faster. That is true in a general sense. Mining stocks convert a gold price move into a larger move in the value of their reserves, because a $100 rise in gold reprices every ounce in the deposit at once, not just the ounces mined this year. It is also true that this cuts the other way. When gold falls, the same mechanism punishes mining stocks harder.
The Difference Between Gold and Silver Stocks
Gold stocks and silver stocks are not interchangeable. Gold producers are generally larger, better financed, and more sensitive to the gold price alone. Silver is mined mostly as a byproduct of other metals, which means pure silver miners are rarer and more volatile. Silver also has an industrial demand story that gold does not, since silver shows up in electronics, solar panels, and batteries. That industrial exposure can help in an economic expansion and hurt in a slowdown.
For most investors, the practical question is whether they want a diversified miner, a pure gold producer, or a junior explorer. Diversified miners give stability and often pay dividends. Pure producers give a cleaner bet on gold. Junior explorers give the biggest possible upside and the biggest possible wipeout. Rickards’s pick, Northern Dynasty Minerals, is closer to the junior end of that spectrum, and it trades on the expectation of a permit rather than on any current production.
How the Pebble Pitch Fits In
Rickards is not really pitching a diversified basket of gold and silver stocks. He is pitching one undeveloped deposit in Alaska, the Pebble Project, which he frames as a “$2 gold mine” with up to $2.7 trillion in claimed in-ground value. That is a very different risk profile from buying a producer or a royalty company. A royalty company collects a percentage of revenue from operating mines, which is the approach we covered in our look at gold royalty stocks. Those are much further down the risk curve than a pre-permit explorer.
The honest framing is that Rickards is selling a lottery ticket with a gold tailwind behind it. The metal is real, the deposit is real, and a favorable court ruling could re-rate the stock sharply. But “best gold and silver stocks” in the conventional sense usually means producers with cash flow, and NAK has none yet.
What to Actually Watch
If you want gold exposure, the starting point is the gold price itself, not a single promotional pick. We have written about the gold price and about gold mining stocks in the context of other promos, and the same framework applies here. Watch the metal, watch the miners’ cost structure, and treat any single “secret mine” story as a concentrated bet rather than a core holding.
Gold and silver stocks have earned their place in a portfolio during this run. The mistake is confusing a real sector tailwind with a guarantee that one pre-revenue explorer will deliver “10-fold profits.” Those are different questions, and Rickards’s pitch is mostly about the second one.
Silver Is a Different Beast
Silver deserves its own line of thinking because it does not behave like gold. Gold is almost purely a monetary asset: central banks hold it, and its price moves mostly on currency and rate expectations. Silver is split. Part of its demand is investment, but a large share is industrial, from electronics to solar panels to batteries. That dual identity means silver tends to move later and faster than gold in a bull market, and it falls harder in a downturn when industrial demand softens.
Pure silver miners are also rarer than gold miners. Most silver comes out of the ground as a byproduct of mining copper, lead, or zinc, so a company billed as a silver play often earns a big slice of its revenue from other metals. If you want silver exposure, check how much of a company’s revenue actually comes from silver before you buy the story.
Position Sizing Is the Whole Game
None of this changes the basic rule. A single pre-permit explorer such as Rickards’s Pebble pick belongs in the speculative slice of a portfolio, the money you can afford to lose, not the core. Gold and silver producers, royalty companies, and broad funds belong in the part you plan to keep. The metal tailwind is real, but a tailwind does not turn a lottery ticket into a savings account.
NewsletterVetter is an independent publication. We receive compensation from some of the services we review through affiliate links. Nothing on this site is investment advice. Always do your own research.