The Skousen Report’s “Trump’s Next Big Stock Buy”: Talon Metals, a $5 Nickel Play Down 21% Since the Tease

The Hook

Dr. Mark Skousen has written more than 25 books on economics and finance, and he opens his current pitch with a claim that is hard to ignore: “In short, I just bought 10,000 shares in a stock virtually no Americans have ever heard of. It trades for around $5. It’s very small. And yet, I believe it could be the next stock the U.S. government takes a major position in.”

The urgency mechanism is pure FOMO wrapped in a geopolitical frame. Skousen points to the Trump administration’s 2025 habit of taking direct equity stakes in companies it considers critical to national security: a 10% position in Intel for $8.9 billion, which he says “nearly doubled in the three months that followed,” and a 15% stake in the rare-earth producer MP Materials, which he says “jumped 216% in 4 months.” His line to readers: “you must be in BEFORE the U.S. makes its move.” The ad sells a new Oxford Club letter called The Skousen Report at $99 a year with a full-year refund period.

This is a re-air. Stock Gumshoe’s teardown was originally published February 24, 2026, and it has been re-shared since without a substantive update. Its own note is candid: “no Trump investment yet,” and the price “remains within a dollar or so of where it was when the ads started running.”

The Big Claim

The specific promise is that one small, roughly $5 miner controls a critical mineral that the U.S. government will soon move to secure, and that getting in before that move happens is the opportunity of a lifetime. The supporting beats are laid out one by one: Indonesia, Russia, and China produce “316 TIMES” the nickel that the U.S. does; Tesla has “signed a binding agreement” for 75,000 metric tonnes of nickel over six years; this company is “the only domestic producer capable of supplying the amount Tesla needs”; and “arguably the greatest resource investor of all-time,” a billionaire founder of 12 resource companies, participated in a $41 million financing. The reveal is Talon Metals, dual-listed on the TSX as TLO and on the U.S. over-the-counter market as TLOFF.

The Mechanism

The reasoning is a supply-chain chokepoint argument. Nickel is a critical battery metal, and the U.S. imports almost all of what it uses. Talon Metals is positioned as the onshore fix: it holds a joint venture with Rio Tinto on the high-grade Tamarack Nickel-Copper-Cobalt Project in central Minnesota, with an earn-in right up to 60% and a current 51% stake. The Tesla agreement, for 75,000 metric tonnes (165 million pounds) of nickel in concentrate plus cobalt and iron byproducts, is real and verifiable. The company also counts Robert Friedland, the mining investor associated with the Voisey’s Bay nickel discovery, among its backers.

What the ad leaves unstated, and what changes the picture, is the timing and the conditionality. The Tesla agreement is contingent on “commercial production,” and the Tamarack mine is not built. It is still working through Minnesota’s environmental permitting process. Stock Gumshoe’s timeline is worth quoting directly: the processing plant in North Dakota could clear permitting as soon as late 2027, the mine could begin construction around 2028, and first production might arrive “sometime in 2029,” with the caveat that “all forecasts for mining projects should be assumed to be pathologically optimistic.”

Meanwhile, Talon has materially changed since the ad was first written. In late 2025 it closed the acquisition of the Eagle Mine and Humboldt Mill in Michigan from Lundin Mining, paid for in shares, which made Lundin Mining and the Lundin Trust more than 20% holders. That deal turned Talon into the operator of the only primary nickel mine currently producing in the United States. The company now reports real revenue: $51.5 million in the second quarter of 2026, net income of $3.2 million, and EBITDA of $11.4 million. Its market capitalization is roughly C$1.0 billion.

The Real Pick

Ticker Company Tease Price Current Price % Change Since Tease
TLOFF (OTC) / TLO.TO (TSX) Talon Metals Corp $5.47 $4.32 -21.02%

The current price is the November 13, 2026 close for the U.S. OTC listing TLOFF, confirmed against Polygon’s previous-close endpoint. Talon trades over the counter in the U.S., so Polygon does not carry a market-cap figure for it; the roughly C$1.0 billion figure above comes from Yahoo Finance’s TLO.TO quote as of the same date.

Does the Math Check Out

The headline claim is not a return projection but a “next government stake” thesis, and on that score the math is thin. The Intel and MP Materials examples are real, but they are hindsight precedents, not a template. The government took those stakes because of specific policy goals around domestic chip and rare-earth capacity; nothing about Talon’s situation guarantees it receives the same treatment. Stock Gumshoe’s re-share note says flatly that there has been “no Trump investment yet.”

The “tiny, virtually unknown $5 stock” framing is the weakest number in the whole pitch. A ~C$1.0 billion market cap with $51.5 million of quarterly revenue is a small-cap producer, not an undiscovered microcap. The ad copy is frozen from February 2026, before the Eagle Mine acquisition closed, and it has not been refreshed to reflect the company Talon actually is today.

There is also a subtle overstatement in the Tesla line. “The only domestic producer capable of supplying the amount Tesla needs” sounds like current capability, but the 75,000-tonne Tesla contract is tied to Tamarack, a mine that does not produce yet. Talon is a domestic nickel producer today because of Eagle, but Eagle’s output is not what feeds the Tesla agreement. The two facts get blurred in the ad.

The most honest number in the entire promotion is the one the ad never mentions: the stock is down about 21% from the $5.47 tease price to the current $4.32. A reader who acted on the original February pitch is underwater, not riding a government-stake windfall.

Finally, the “March 5” deadline is not a catalyst. Stock Gumshoe traced it to Talon’s special shareholder meeting, held to approve share-structure changes tied to the Lundin deal. It has no connection to government support. It exists, in the site’s words, because “if you’re trying to sell a subscription, you need a deadline to spur people to action.”

The Verdict

Talon Metals is a genuinely interesting company, and this promo wraps a real thesis in stale framing. The nickel-supply story is real, the Rio Tinto joint venture is real, the Tesla agreement is real, and the Eagle Mine makes Talon the only U.S. primary nickel producer. But the pitch’s reason to buy now, the imminent government stake, is speculation with no evidence behind it, and the “tiny $5 undiscovered” framing no longer describes the company. The stock being down 21% since the tease is the honest scoreboard. This is a company worth understanding on its own merits, not a trade to make because the government might tap it on the shoulder.

What They Got Right

  1. Nickel is a genuinely critical mineral, and domestic nickel security is a real policy theme with real money behind it. Talon has already been awarded roughly $115 million from the Department of Energy and $20 million from the Department of Defense for its North Dakota processing site, which is concrete evidence that the onshoring argument is not pure marketing.
  2. The Tesla supply agreement is a verifiable fact: 75,000 metric tonnes of nickel in concentrate over an estimated six years, contingent on production. That is a meaningful commercial signal regardless of the mine’s status.
  3. Robert Friedland is a legitimate heavyweight. His association with the Voisey’s Bay discovery is a real credential, and his participation in a $41 million financing is a substantive vote of confidence.
  4. Skousen’s own credentials are real. More than 25 books on economics and finance is a genuine body of work, and his framing of the government-stake trend is timely and well-observed.
  5. The pick itself has improved fundamentally since the ad was written. The Eagle Mine acquisition gives Talon cash flow, a production footprint, and the Lundin family as a 20%-plus shareholder, which is a materially stronger company than the one the ad first described.

What They Got Wrong

  1. The “very small, trades around $5, virtually no Americans have ever heard of” framing is stale by roughly nine months. The company now has a ~C$1.0 billion market cap and real revenue, and presenting it as a hidden microcap misstates what a buyer is actually getting.
  2. “The only domestic producer capable of supplying the amount Tesla needs” conflates a future, not-yet-built mine with current capability. The Tesla contract depends on Tamarack reaching commercial production, which is still years away under optimistic timelines.
  3. The “next government stake” thesis is presented with more confidence than the evidence supports. The Trump-buy-in angle originated in Skousen’s own conference conversation with Friedland, which Stock Gumshoe flags as scuttlebutt, not intelligence.
  4. The “March 5” deadline is manufactured urgency. It points at a routine shareholder meeting, not a government-investment catalyst, and using it as a call to action is misleading about what is actually happening.
  5. The tease performance is quietly negative. Down 21% from the $5.47 tease price, the pick has not delivered the implied upside, and the re-air runs anyway because the ad copy is evergreen.

NewsletterVetter is an independent publication. We receive compensation from some of the services we review through affiliate links. Nothing on this site is investment advice. Always do your own research.