“If you could only buy 5 stocks today to hold through 2026 and beyond, which would they be?” That is the question The Motley Fool’s newest year-ahead report opens with, and it is a sharper version of the service’s long-running annual picks list. Tom and David Gardner, who co-founded The Motley Fool in 1993 and launched Stock Advisor in 2002, narrowed the usual “10 top stock picks” down to five names and asked readers to treat the list as a buy-and-hold answer key. Ten months later, we can measure how that answer key has actually done, and the scoreboard is the most honest thing about the pitch.
The Five Names
The basket is a genuinely spread-out collection. It runs across fashion, coffee, Latin American e-commerce, food delivery, and space, which is not five clones of one theme. The names are Aritzia (ATZAF), the Canadian fashion retailer building a fast-growing US business; Dutch Bros (BROS), the drive-thru coffee chain with a devoted following; MercadoLibre (MELI), the dominant Latin American marketplace with a fintech arm bolted on; DoorDash (DASH), the US food-delivery leader moving into grocery and convenience; and Rocket Lab (RKLB), the space company the Fool has recommended repeatedly. The report’s own framing calls these “the kinds of companies we believe are best positioned to lead the next market cycle.”
The Ten-Month Scoreboard
Here is where the pitch meets reality. Of the five names, three carried a verifiable recommendation price. Dutch Bros was recommended at $60.12 and closed at $32.78 on November 20, 2026, a decline of about 45%. MercadoLibre was recommended at $2,148.62 and closed at $1,355.00, a decline of about 37%. Aritzia was recommended at $89.33 and closed at $94.47, a gain of about 6%. DoorDash and Rocket Lab have no authoritative tease price in the teardown, so they sit outside the scoreboard. Two of the three verifiable picks are down roughly 40% in under a year, even as the broader market kept climbing. That is not a dismissal of the service; it is a precise statement of what happened to this particular basket.
The Outlier Math
The reason this happens is not a flaw in the strategy, and it is worth understanding because it is the whole engine of the Gardner approach. The service’s average returns depend heavily on outliers: a few enormous winners, some of them up 10,000%, overwhelm a much larger pile of losers that fall 50% to 90%. The brothers are open about this. Their method is to buy good businesses and hold them for five years or more, accepting that many picks will lose half their value while a handful of outliers do the heavy lifting. That is an intellectually honest way to run a stock-picking service, and it means any single name in the basket can lose half its value while the aggregate record still looks excellent. The “5 stocks” format concentrates that dynamic: fewer names, each carrying more of the burden, which is exactly what the scoreboard is showing in miniature.
The Offer and the Honest Read
The product on offer is Stock Advisor itself, at $99 for the first year, $199 on renewal, with a 30-day refund. For a service that has genuinely called Amazon, Netflix, Nvidia, Shopify, and Booking early over the years, that is a fair price, and it comes with something rarer than it sounds: a full, visible recommendation history rather than a cherry-picked highlight reel. What to keep in mind is that the list is best treated as a starting point for research, not a can’t-miss basket. MercadoLibre is a great company you can now buy about a third cheaper than the report did. Aritzia is the one pick that has proven its thesis so far. Dutch Bros is an expensive story you would want to see produce real free cash flow before paying 80 times forward earnings. Entry price matters even when the holding period is forever.
The scoreboard also carries a lesson about timing that the report itself does not emphasize. A great company bought at a stretched price can still hand you a loss for a long stretch, and the basket shows it in real time. MercadoLibre is the same excellent business today that it was when the report recommended it, yet anyone who bought at the recommendation price is now down about a third. Aritzia, the least obviously exciting of the three verifiable names, is the one that worked, largely because it was not priced for perfection the way the others were. Dutch Bros, at 80 times forward adjusted earnings, was priced for exactly that, and the market has since cut that multiple. None of this makes the picks bad businesses. It makes the point that the question of which stocks to buy has two parts: which companies, and at what price. The report answers the first part well. The second part is the homework it leaves to you.
For the coffee pick’s story, see our Dutch Bros stock piece. For the marketplace at the center of the basket, see our MercadoLibre stock piece. And for the space name, see our Rocket Lab coverage.
Ready to see the research? Click here to view the 5 Stocks for 2026 and Beyond report.
NewsletterVetter is an independent publication. We receive compensation from some of the services we review through affiliate links. Nothing on this site is investment advice. Always do your own research.