Starbucks (SBUX) is not one of the five picks in The Motley Fool’s “5 Stocks for 2026 and Beyond” basket, but it is the incumbent against which the basket’s coffee pick is best measured. Dutch Bros, the drive-thru challenger the Gardner brothers’ team selected, is racing to become the kind of national coffee brand that Starbucks already is. This is a competitive-context explainer, so it stays at the descriptive level: the teardown does not name Starbucks or carry a Starbucks price or store count, and this article will not invent any.
The Incumbent: The World’s Largest Coffeehouse Chain
Starbucks is the world’s largest coffeehouse chain, and its store base dwarfs Dutch Bros’ roughly 1,100 drive-thru locations many times over. It is a global business, with a presence across North America, Europe, Asia, and beyond, and a brand that has become shorthand for specialty coffee itself. That scale and maturity define the business in a way the challenger simply does not have yet.
The Starbucks model is built around the third place, a comfortable store where customers sit, work, and linger, in addition to grabbing coffee on the go. It is a fundamentally different bet from the drive-thru-only format that Dutch Bros runs. One optimizes for dwell time and ticket size in a full cafe; the other optimizes for speed, throughput, and customer loyalty from the driver’s seat.
The Two Models, Side by Side
The contrast between the two is the clearest way to understand what the basket is actually betting on. Starbucks is a mature, dividend-paying global chain. Its growth comes from steady store expansion, menu innovation, and a loyalty program, and it returns cash to shareholders along the way. Dutch Bros is a hyper-growth drive-thru challenger concentrated in the western United States, reinvesting heavily to open hundreds of new locations each year and paying no dividend because every dollar goes back into growth.
Neither model is wrong. They serve different investors with different goals. The income-oriented investor who wants a proven global brand with a dividend will find Starbucks more natural. The growth investor who wants unit expansion and is willing to accept a richer valuation and little current free cash flow will find Dutch Bros more interesting.
The Promo’s Thesis: Growth Is in the Drive-Thru
The basket chose Dutch Bros, and the reasoning tells you where the Gardner team thinks the growth is. The promo frames Dutch Bros as a brand with “a fanatical following serving coffee to customers who never leave their cars,” opening hundreds of new locations each year. The thesis is that the drive-thru, high-service model is where the growth will come from, because it is cheaper to build, faster to scale, and more attuned to how Americans increasingly buy their coffee, on the go.
Starbucks is the backdrop that makes that thesis legible. Against a giant that already owns the sit-down coffee ritual, the challenger’s pitch is that the future of coffee looks more like a drive-thru lane than a lounge, and that the company best positioned to capture that shift is the one built around it from day one.
The Dividend Versus Reinvestment Trade-Off
The clearest way to see the difference between the incumbent and the challenger is to follow the money. Starbucks generates enough cash to both fund its own growth and return a dividend to shareholders, a sign of a mature business with more earnings than it can sensibly reinvest. Dutch Bros is the opposite: every dollar of profit goes back into new stores, which is why it pays no dividend and shows little current free cash flow even as its location count climbs.
Neither path is a flaw. A mature chain returning cash is doing exactly what it should, and a growth company reinvesting everything is doing exactly what it should. The difference is what each investor is buying. With the incumbent you are buying a proven cash machine and a steady payout. With the challenger you are buying the future store count and accepting that the rewards, if they come, arrive years down the road. The basket made the second choice, and the cost of paying up for growth that has not yet arrived is part of why that pick trades where it does today.
The Honest Read
The useful takeaway is that the coffee market is not a single story. It is an incumbent with scale, maturity, and a dividend, and a challenger with growth, speed, and a much richer valuation. The basket bet on the challenger, and whether that bet pays off depends on whether Dutch Bros can keep opening stores and hold its cult-like loyalty long enough to justify the price.
For the challenger’s full story, see our Dutch Bros stock piece and our broader look at coffee stocks. For the service behind these picks, see our teardown of the Motley Fool Stock Advisor.
Ready to see the research? Click here to view the 5 Stocks for 2026 and Beyond report.
NewsletterVetter is an independent publication. We receive compensation from some of the services we review through affiliate links. Nothing on this site is investment advice. Always do your own research.