Coffee is a deceptively good business, and the reason is habit. A daily coffee buyer returns without being reminded, spends a small amount each time, and rarely switches once a routine forms. That repeat-purchase behavior is what makes the category attractive to long-term investors, and it is the engine behind the two names that dominate the conversation: Starbucks as the mature incumbent, and Dutch Bros (BROS) as the fast-growing drive-thru challenger. The Motley Fool’s Stock Advisor team, led by Tom and David Gardner, placed Dutch Bros in its “5 Stocks for 2026 and Beyond” basket as the coffee pick.

The Two Sides of the Coffee Trade

The coffee-stock space splits into two very different stories. Starbucks is the incumbent, a global brand with tens of thousands of locations, a massive loyalty program, and a supply chain that spans the world. Its growth today is incremental rather than explosive, and its valuation reflects a mature company. It is the safe, familiar name, and it sets the benchmark every challenger is measured against.

Dutch Bros is the opposite end of the spectrum. It is a hyper-growth story built entirely around the drive-thru, with about 1,100 locations and roughly $2.2 billion in systemwide sales. The company is not trying to be Starbucks; it is trying to be the fast, friendly, drive-thru-first alternative. The promo describes the thesis in vivid terms, a chain with “a fanatical following serving coffee to customers who never leave their cars” and one that is “opening hundreds of new locations each year.” We compare the two names in detail in our Starbucks stock piece, which lays out the incumbent’s position.

Why the Drive-Thru Model Works

The drive-thru is more than a convenience, it is an economic model. A drive-thru location needs less seating, less front-of-house staff, and less square footage than a cafe, which lowers the cost to open each new store. It also turns cars into a queue that keeps throughput high during the morning rush, the most profitable hours of the coffee day. Dutch Bros leans into this hard, designing its stores around the window rather than the dining room.

That model has a second advantage: it travels. A drive-thru-first format is easy to replicate across suburban and exurban markets, which is where Dutch Bros has concentrated its expansion. The brand’s high-service culture, where employees are trained to be upbeat and familiar with regulars, is the piece competitors have found hardest to copy. For the full breakdown of the chain’s growth thesis and unit economics, see our Dutch Bros stock piece.

The Price Is the Problem

The uncomfortable part of the Dutch Bros story is the valuation. The stock trades around 80 times forward adjusted earnings, which is a price that assumes years of flawless execution. The company is still reinvesting heavily in new locations, so current free cash flow is thin, and the share count has grown slightly faster than systemwide sales since the IPO.

The scoreboard shows what that price can cost. Dutch Bros closed at $32.78 on November 20, 2026, against a $60.12 tease price in the original report, down about 45%. The business did not break; the multiple did. When a stock priced for perfection meets any hint of doubt, the drawdown is fast and deep. Starbucks, by contrast, trades on a much lower multiple because the market no longer expects explosive growth from it. The trade-off is real: you pay for Dutch Bros’s growth, and if that growth stumbles even slightly, you pay twice.

The Honest Read

Coffee is a wonderful category for patient investors because the habit is so sticky. Dutch Bros has built something genuinely differentiated inside it, a drive-thru-first brand with a culture that keeps customers coming back and a clear path to thousands more locations. None of that changed when the stock fell 45%; what changed was the market’s willingness to pay 80 times forward earnings for it.

The lesson is about entry price, not about the business. A great growth story bought at a great price can compound for a decade; the same story bought at 80 times forward earnings leaves no cushion for the inevitable stumble. For the space name that rounds out the basket, our Rocket Lab coverage explains the fifth pick, and the buy-and-hold philosophy behind all five runs through the whole report.

For a coffee investor, the practical question is how much growth you are willing to pay for up front. Starbucks gives you a mature, dividend-paying business at a modest multiple, while Dutch Bros gives you a fast-growing challenger at a premium. Both can work in a portfolio, and both serve the same underlying habit. The discipline is matching your holding period to the price: a premium multiple is easier to justify when you plan to hold for a decade and harder to justify when the first stumble costs 45%.

Ready to see the research? Click here to view the 5 Stocks for 2026 and Beyond report.

NewsletterVetter is an independent publication. We receive compensation from some of the services we review through affiliate links. Nothing on this site is investment advice. Always do your own research.